Trusted by architects & contractors in 140+ countries. Request a Quote →

McNichols Steel, Metal Cladding & Small-Order Buying: A Purchasing Admin's FAQ

I'm not a metal fabricator. I'm the person who runs purchasing for a 180-person company—roughly $500K a year across twelve or so vendors, split between facilities, maintenance, and the occasional small construction project. Steel building materials fall under my desk because no one else wants them.

Over the past few years I've ordered everything from handrail systems to perforated panels to a single pallet of metal siding for a breakroom expansion. Here are the questions I get asked the most—by new procurement admins, by our ops manager, and by sales reps who are trying to figure out whether I'm worth calling back.

Q1: Wait—is McNichols a steel company or an auto parts place?

This one comes up more than you'd think. I've been on the phone with someone who found "holbrook auto parts mcnichols" in a search and asked me whether we were ordering brake components from a building-materials supplier. No. Those are two different things, and a fair number of people conflate them.

McNichols is a metals distributor and fabricator—grating, wire mesh, perforated panels, cladding, handrail, stair systems, structural steel, formwork, elevator components. Holbrook Auto Parts is a separate business entirely. If you're sourcing steel building materials and you accidentally land on an auto parts page, hit the back button. If you're searching for "mcnichols steel" and wondering whether it's a mill like Nucor, it isn't—it's a distributor-fabricator that buys from mills and sells in the shapes contractors actually need.

Q2: What's the practical difference between "metal siding" and "metal cladding"?

People use them interchangeably. They aren't the same. Siding is generally a wall finish—it sheds water, it looks a certain way, and its performance specs revolve around weather resistance. Cladding is a broader term: a protective or decorative skin over a structural substrate, and it may be doing more work—rain screen, thermal break, fire performance, architectural appearance.

When a rep quotes you "metal siding," ask what the panel system actually is. The deliverable, the attachment method, and the warrantable use case may all be different. That distinction matters because a spec that reads "metal siding, 26-gauge, painted" tells a fabricator almost nothing about what you actually need for a building envelope.

Q3: How do I write a metal cladding specification guide that doesn't waste everyone's time?

Here's what I've learned from getting this wrong twice. A usable spec needs—at minimum—the substrate (what the cladding is attaching to), the panel profile, the metal and gauge, the finish (paint system, substrate, warranty term), the attachment system, the flashing and trim scope, and the applicable code and testing standard.

Don't just name a standard—say which one and why. ASTM A653 covers steel sheet with zinc coatings; ASTM A123 covers hot-dip galvanizing; if fire performance is in play, say so upfront. If you're not sure which standard applies, ask. I once wrote "galvanized" in a spec and got three wildly different quotes back, which told me the word meant three different things to three different suppliers. That's a red flag that the spec, not the pricing, was the problem.

Q4: Are small orders actually worth a supplier's time?

I'm going to be blunt: this is the part of the job that makes me want to scream.

We've placed orders in the low hundreds of dollars for test panels or a single replacement section. Some vendors treat that like a personal insult. Others treat it like the beginning of a relationship—and the ones who did are the ones we now call for five-figure orders. When I was building out our vendor list in 2022, the supplier who took my $380 sample order seriously is still the one we spec on projects today. Small doesn't mean unimportant—it means potential.

To be fair, minimum order quantities exist for real reasons. Setting up a line for 200 feet of panel and setting it up for 20,000 feet cost roughly the same on the front end, and small orders can eat into a supplier's margin. I get that. But there's a difference between "our MOQ is X and here's why" and being made to feel like a nuisance for asking.

Q5: Does OEM or private-label work apply to smaller buyers, or is that a big-fish thing?

It's more accessible than you'd expect. Private label on metal products usually means the supplier applies your label or mark to a product they already manufacture to a standard spec, rather than engineering a new product. For our purposes, it mattered because our brand shows up on the packaging and the warranty paperwork our facilities team hands off.

That said—verify what's actually private-labeled. I've had a supplier call something "OEM" when what they meant was "we'll put a sticker on a commodity panel." That's fine, but call it what it is. Ask who holds the warranty, who handles the spec sheet, and what happens when a panel fails.

Q6: What hidden costs should I plan for on a steel building materials order?

Freight is the one that bites. It's rarely in the quoted unit price, and it swings based on length, weight, and whether the load needs a flatbed with a liftgate. Protective packaging on finished panels—if you don't pay for it, you pay for touch-up labor later. Crating for small-lot hardware. Restocking fees if you over-order. And cut charges if the fabricator has to trim stock lengths.

I don't have a magic percentage for you here. Honestly, I'm not sure why freight quotes vary so much between suppliers on what looks like an identical load—my best guess is it's about how they consolidate shipments and how much buffer they build into the quote. What I do now: ask for "delivered to job site" pricing plus the line-item breakdown, so I can see what's actually comparable.

Q7: Any final advice for a purchasing admin who just got handed a cladding project?

Yes—get the spec reviewed before you shop the price. I learned this the expensive way in 2023, when I sourced what I thought was a great number on perforated panels, confirmed the PO, and then spent two weeks second-guessing whether the gauge was right for the application. It was, but only by luck. Now I have a rule: any building-materials order over $2,000 gets a second pair of eyes—either our maintenance lead or the fabricator's technical contact—before the PO goes out.

I can only speak to a mid-size commercial operation with predictable, modest order volume. If you're running a multi-site construction firm with $5M in annual metals spend, your leverage and your playbook will look nothing like mine. But if you're the person who has to explain a bad delivery to a VP, the checklist above will save you some grief.

Emilia Novak
Emilia Novak

Emilia Novak is a flooring and architectural-surfaces analyst covering ceramic and porcelain tile, natural stone, resilient flooring, underlayments, countertops, adhesives, grout, and installation accessories. She uses ASTM C373 and ASTM C648 test evidence while comparing water absorption, breaking strength, slab flatness, substrate moisture, joint width, slip resistance, and installed tolerances. Her specification guides help architects, contractors, and buyers match surface systems to traffic, wet-area exposure, maintenance demands, and substrate conditions.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *